Five charts that show whether Trump created the ‘greatest economy ever’

The US President is promising a strong post-Covid recovery but his economic record is patchy after the first term

Donald Trump economy

“We built the greatest economy in the history of the world, and now we are doing it again,” Donald Trump boasted to supporters in the swing state of Michigan on the campaign trail.

The US president has been touting his economic record and insisting he can lead America to boom years once again following the pandemic. 

But voters are becoming less confident in Trump’s handling of the economy with one poll recently suggesting that Joe Biden was trusted more following the huge Covid recession and surge in unemployment. From trade wars to tax cuts, how has the US economy fared under the president?

Trump misses lofty growth promises

Trump claimed he could boost annual GDP growth to “4pc, 5pc or even 6pc” but failed to reach his lofty ambitions despite the US economy largely defying the global slowdown before the pandemic. 

The President's corporate tax cuts in 2017 were a huge stimulus jolt for the American economy but the trade war became a headwind, triggering an industrial recession and slowing global growth, particularly in the eurozone and China.

Many voters will excuse the President for the huge 31pc annualised plunge in GDP suffered during the pandemic-hit second quarter of 2020, but Trump never achieved the 4pc growth he promised.

Growth was only marginally quicker in his first three years prior to Covid-19 than Barack Obama’s final three years in the Oval Office with the longest economic expansion in US history ending on his watch.

Did ‘America First’ bring back factory jobs? 

A key pledge of the President was to revive US manufacturing and bring back jobs offshored to the likes of China and Mexico.

“Made in America” has endured a decades-long decline and Trump struck a chord with voters in the former manufacturing hubs and swing states in the Rust Belt, such as Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.

The pandemic wiped out a decade of jobs growth in factories but the President’s record in manufacturing before Covid-19 was mixed.

The Economic Policy Institute estimates that employment gains were largely on par with Trump’s predecessor Barack Obama, while factories have continued to close despite his efforts to pressure firms to bring back plants.

Biden has also made reinvigorating US manufacturing a key policy pledge but, like Trump, he will be trying to hold back the tide as automation and fierce overseas competition hurt American factories.

Closing the trade deficit with China?

Slashing the trade deficit with China and the trade war have been a key vote winner for Trump in former industrial hubs.

He can claim victory in reducing the gap between imports and exports to China, suggesting that tariffs slapped on goods worth hundreds of billions of dollars have worked. But analysts warn that does not tell the full story.

The overall trade balance has been largely unchanged with the US now importing more from the EU and Mexico, for example. There is growing evidence of transshipment to get around higher US tariffs, meaning Chinese firms avoided costs on their products by sending them via another country such as Vietnam.

“Trade policy uncertainty has given way to larger concerns in 2020, but the US elections could bring them back,” says Joanna Konings, economist at ING. "If President Trump is re-elected, new tariff increases, and new trade wars, are likely.”

Pandemic reverses jobs boom

US workers were enjoying the lowest unemployment rate in 50 years before the pandemic turned the jobs boom to bust.

The lack of a furlough scheme in the US caused unemployment to rocket to its highest level since the Great Depression with Trump opting to boost jobless benefits instead. However, unemployment has fallen rapidly since the peak earlier this year while furlough schemes may have only delayed job losses and kept workers in suspended animation in Europe.

After surging to 15pc in April, the US unemployment rate has dropped to 7.9pc in September - still more than double the levels seen before Covid-19.  Unemployment is mixed across the key swing states with Pennsylvania, Michigan and Ohio suffering slightly higher joblessness than the national average.

However, the improvement in the labour market has slowed markedly in recent months with only a small drop in unemployment between August and September. 

Both candidates have made job creation a key part of their campaigns but economists expect Biden to boost employment more than the President. Credit rating agency Moody’s predicts that Biden’s plans will create 7.4m more jobs during the recovery.

Stocks on rollercoaster ride during Trump presidency

The stock market has had a rollercoaster four years under Trump, soaring to record highs and then collapsing into the fastest bear market in history after Covid-19 struck.

The S&P 500, New York’s major stock index, has gained 55pc since his shock victory in 2016 with the President’s tax cuts and help from looser monetary policy at the US central bank powering shares higher.

The President appears to no longer be the stock market’s darling, however. Analysts on Wall Street have argued that US markets have positioned themselves for a “blue wave” in recent weeks as Biden has edged towards victory.

Investors have latched onto hopes that the Democrat will use huge stimulus to bolster the US economy and be less combative on trade policy.

Jussi Hiljanen, strategist at SEB, explains that a “blue sweep” where Democrats control the presidency, House of Representatives and the Senate “would provide least resistance to a large-scale fiscal stimulus, which would be more positive for stocks”. 

He adds: “A divided Congress would make any agreements on a large-scale stimulus more difficult and as such be less positive for risky assets.”